✕

Search

A gradient background transitioning from black at the top, to dark blue, then green, and finally fading to white at the bottom.
Back to case studies

Converting Visitors into Donors with Smart, Automated Follow Up

Leveraging e-commerce tactics for fundraising.

Explore More Digital Case Studies
Brown rock formation under blue sky at daytime.
10x

stronger response!

Table of Contents

  • No headers found.

Situation

To boost online donor conversion, the National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA) piloted an innovative “abandoned donation” strategy—an approach adapted from the e-commerce world and customized for nonprofit fundraising.

Solution

We integrated automated technology with the donation form to identify when donors navigated away from the donation page before completing their gift. This triggered a personalized email reminder, making it easier for donors to return to the site to finish their donation. Then, to intervene even earlier in the process, we added an exit intent pop-up on the donation page to encourage visitors to complete their gift before leaving the donation page.

A website pop-up message overlays a donation page for the National Parks Conservation Association, prompting converting visitors to finish their donation and help protect US national parks. The background remains partially visible.
An email from the National Parks Conservation Association encourages converting visitors into supporters, featuring a sunset landscape over a park and a prominent “Complete My Gift” button.
A National Parks Conservation Association email urging the reader to complete their donation, emphasizing the importance of protecting parks and converting visitors into supporters, and featuring a “Complete My Gift” button at the bottom.
22%

higher average gift

10x

stronger response rate

Success

The results were impressive: these “reminder” emails generated gifts with an average donation 22% higher than organic web joins and achieved a response rate ten times stronger than standard email appeals. Even better, once the automation was built, the system continued to engage new potential donors month after month—requiring virtually no ongoing management while delivering steady incremental revenue.

This approach worked because it met donors where they already were—online, in real time. Life may have pulled them away, but a friendly reminder and a one-click path back to giving was all they needed to complete their act of support. It’s a low-touch, high-impact way to ensure that every expression of interest has the potential to grow into lasting stewardship.

We know what works, when to test, and how to turn insight into action. Let’s work together to boost your online donor engagement.

Let’s Start Today!
A gradient background transitioning from black at the top to dark blue, then blue, and finally green at the bottom.

Let’s Work Together

Avalon Consulting partners with nonprofits of all sizes to create data-driven, creative campaigns that inspire donors and drive results. Let’s connect and explore how we can help your mission grow.

Avalon staff a the Spring 2026 All-Staff Retreat