Avalon Dispatch 11.17.2026

•

In today’s Dispatch, you will find the push-pull between political and charitable giving, dignity-led storytelling, when to call a meeting, client celebrations, feathered friends, and more.

A dark blue banner with the words THE DISPATCH BY AVALON; DISPATCH is in large yellow letters, while the other text is smaller and white. Two sets of triangular shapes point toward the center text.

Dear friends,

For many people, last week’s Microsoft outage forced a pause from email. This opened up some interesting space for focus, but it also created a backlog that took time to work through. Notwithstanding the curveball, Avalon is on track and on schedule. I hope you and your team are hanging in there!

This week, look for your Avalon team to communicate plans for GivingTuesday, including what to expect for Thanksgiving schedules and any checklists still in play. GivingTuesday is the culmination of months of planning and diligent preparation, and Avalon is ready. Good luck to everyone in the final stretch.

From Elections to the Giving Season

Senior VP of Digital Chris Maddocks shared an interesting study from the National Bureau of Economic Research, which suggests political and charitable giving act as substitutes. Based on comparative data from the American Red Cross and the Federal Election Commission, the impact is relatively balanced: “A 1% marginal increase in charitable donations leads to a 0.53% decline in political donations, and a 1% marginal increase in political donations crowds out charitable giving by 0.59%.” In other words, when one goes up, the other goes down.

This comes as no surprise to veteran fundraisers, but it does highlight the value of attention. Over the next few weeks, campaign ads will give way to emails, direct mail, digital advertising, texts, social posts, and fundraising appeals from nonprofits, all competing for donors’ attention and a chance to show why their mission matters. And collectively, Giving Tuesday provides a shared moment to draw attention to the nonprofit sector’s good work throughout the world. Avalon will ensure that every client has the data, the strategy, the creative, and the expert execution they need to lead the way.

Dignity-Led Storytelling

Senior VP Margot O’Leary highlighted an International Fundraising Congress session on Dignity-Led Fundraising Narratives, led by Tehzeeb Lalani and Madan Padaki of the Head Held High Foundation. She noted that the session aligned closely with our team’s work on dignified storytelling through Avalon’s Fundraising Choice Points Initiative.

One exercise in particular drove the importance home:  

We were asked to imagine we were seeking funding from a foundation for ourselves, to help us accomplish something important. Then we wrote two versions of our pitch: The first was supposed to make the reader cry, focusing on our struggles and desperation. The second focused on what the funding would allow us to accomplish. I was genuinely startled by how awful the first version felt to write. I had to make myself sound helpless, desperate, and almost pathetic to gain sympathy. It felt like I was stripping away my own dignity to convince someone I deserved their help. The second version was an entirely different experience. I was still asking for support, but I was doing it from a place of possibility rather than helplessness. 

“We know that emotion is essential to effective fundraising, but there’s a big difference between helping donors understand someone’s circumstances and defining that person entirely by their struggles.” — Senior VP Margot O’Leary

Meeting or Email?

By now, most professionals are laughing along with “this could have been an email” memes. However, deciding when to call a meeting isn’t always obvious. For tough cases, Harvard Business Review’s “Should I Hold a Meeting?” flow chart walks you through four options: (1) scheduling time for strategic thinking, (2) doing the work, (3) sending an email, and (4) scheduling a meeting. Or visit shoulditbeameeting.com for a quick quiz to determine your next step (and throwback GIFs from The Office).

Client Celebrations

Avalon clients always host inspiring events, and this fall was no exception. Most recently, our team was honored to support and celebrate Humane World for Animals’ efforts to protect animals worldwide and SAGE USA’s impactful work on behalf of LGBTQ+ elders. Thank you for having us!

(L) Alice Murphy, SB Birnie, Allison Porter, and Jackie Libby get in the spirit at Humane World for Animals’ To the Rescue! gala. (R) Bill Tucker and Lindsay Marino Long celebrate with honorees at the 2026 SAGE Awards & Gala.

Adopt a Turkey 

Finally, one of my favorite Thanksgiving traditions is Farm Sanctuary’s annual Adopt-a-Turkey campaign. In addition to feathered introductions and opportunities to adopt both single birds and flocks, they have a cute quiz to help you find your “turkey twin.” (I’m a Tutu. 🦃) Kudos to Farm Sanctuary for this creative campaign, which supports the animals and delivers on both engagement and donations year after year. 

Take care,

A handwritten signature in cursive, drawn with a gray line on a transparent background.
Photograph of Allison Porter, a person with shoulder-length brown hair wearing a light blue blazer and a black-and-white striped top, standing outdoors with green foliage in the background.

Allison Porter
President
Avalon Consulting Group
[email protected]

Let’s Work Together

Avalon Consulting partners with nonprofits of all sizes to create data-driven, creative campaigns that inspire donors and drive results. Let’s connect and explore how we can help your mission grow.